The Debate Over the Ten Commandments in Texas Classrooms

Sun Nov 23 2025 11:56:12 GMT+0200 (Eastern European Standard Time)

In Texas, the mandate to display the Ten Commandments in public school classrooms has sparked resignations, legal battles, and ethical concerns among educators and students.

Texas law now requires the display of the Ten Commandments in classrooms, leading to significant resistance from educators who choose to resign rather than comply. The law's constitutionality is being challenged in courts, prompting school districts to navigate complex dilemmas involving religious freedom and educational duty. As parents and students debate the implications, the community finds itself in a heated discussion about the intersection of education and personal beliefs.

The implementation of a Texas law mandating the posting of the Ten Commandments in public school classrooms has ignited a fierce debate among educators, students, and parents. Theater teacher Gigi Cervantes, for instance, resigned over the mandate, declaring, I just was not going to be a part of forcing or imposing religious doctrine onto my students. Her departure reflects broader concerns about the law's implications for educational integrity and religious freedom.

In response to the law, some districts have already rolled out plans to display the Commandments, leading to a rush of donations of posters. For example, officials in the Frisco Independent School District spent $1,800 to print 5,000 posters, despite the law only requiring that such displays be donated. Others like the Galveston Independent School District halted the posting until the law's constitutionality is clarified in the courts.

Legal experts argue that the mandate potentially violates the First Amendment, while federal courts have already ruled against similar laws in Arkansas and Louisiana. As the situation evolves, the law is poised to provoke further challenges in the U.S. Supreme Court.

In classrooms across Texas, the Commandments are sparking discussions among students regarding their significance. Sixteen-year-old Madison Creed at Carthage High School expressed that the topic quickly became a focal point, igniting a variety of viewpoints among her peers: Everybody had their opinion about it... a lot of us don’t agree with it, but there is the other portion of the school that does. This sentiment illustrates the divide among students regarding the intersection of faith and public education.

As the community grapples with the law's ramifications, educators like Rachel Preston share concerns for students who may not identify as Christian, feeling that the law sends a conflicting message in public education. Thus far, teachers continue to voice questions about their rights and responsibilities in navigating discussions on the matter.

In the face of rising tensions, some community members, such as Lorne Liechty from Rockwall, rally in support of the Commandments, seeing them as foundational to both Christian faith and societal conduct: These are just really good guides for human behavior, he stated.

As Texas schools grapple with the mandate, the future remains uncertain, with educators, parents, and students anxiously awaiting court rulings that could reshape the educational landscape.