NEW YORK — In a gripping courtroom battle, Luigi Mangione, 27, is fighting to exclude critical evidence from the ongoing trial regarding the murder of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson. This evidence includes a loaded gun magazine that police found wrapped in underwear during his arrest at a McDonald's in Pennsylvania. The initial discovery led authorities to believe they had apprehended the right suspect for the murder that occurred in Manhattan just five days earlier.
It’s him, dude. It’s him, 100%, an officer was captured saying on body camera footage, illustrating their conviction in identifying Mangione as the alleged shooter.
During a pretrial hearing, which commenced on December 1, Mangione's defense argued that the evidence, including the loaded gun and a notebook containing writings hinting at violent intentions, should be excluded due to the lack of a search warrant at the time of the arrest. Furthermore, prosecutors claim the handgun found corroborates the weapon used in Thompson's execution.
Amidst the debate, courtroom and behavioral dynamics have grown tense. As Mangione remained attentive while reviewing evidence—an array of items pulled from his backpack—they attempted to challenge the details surrounding both the legality of the search and the content of the notebook that seemed to express a grudge against health insurers, and disdain for corporate America.
Prosecutors allege that phrases found written on the ammunition mimic jargon often employed by insurance companies to deny claim payments. The investigation remains underway as the evidence unfolds and both sides prepare for the next phase of the trial.
It’s him, dude. It’s him, 100%, an officer was captured saying on body camera footage, illustrating their conviction in identifying Mangione as the alleged shooter.
During a pretrial hearing, which commenced on December 1, Mangione's defense argued that the evidence, including the loaded gun and a notebook containing writings hinting at violent intentions, should be excluded due to the lack of a search warrant at the time of the arrest. Furthermore, prosecutors claim the handgun found corroborates the weapon used in Thompson's execution.
Amidst the debate, courtroom and behavioral dynamics have grown tense. As Mangione remained attentive while reviewing evidence—an array of items pulled from his backpack—they attempted to challenge the details surrounding both the legality of the search and the content of the notebook that seemed to express a grudge against health insurers, and disdain for corporate America.
Prosecutors allege that phrases found written on the ammunition mimic jargon often employed by insurance companies to deny claim payments. The investigation remains underway as the evidence unfolds and both sides prepare for the next phase of the trial.





















