In a shocking turn of events on Hawaii’s Big Island, prosecutors allege that the killings of three men over 60 were “especially heinous, atrocious, or cruel.” The alleged murders took place in the remote Puna region, an area known for its jungle‑like terrain and off‑grid lifestyle.
Suspect Jacob Baker, 36, is charged with the murders of two 69‑year‑olds—Robert Shine and John Carse—and a 79‑year‑old (identified as Frederick Morse). Baker appeared in court on Monday, where a judge granted a defense request for a mental fitness examination. Prosecutors also argue that Baker had known the victims were older men and that the killings were of exceptional depravity.
The bodies were discovered in brutal and varied circumstances:
- Robert Shine was found submerged in a cement pond with fractured ribs and strangulation marks.
- Frederick Morse was discovered in his bed with several severed fingers.
- John Carse was found face‑down in dirt under corrugated roofing, the autopsy revealing cuts to his face, severed neck muscles, a broken jaw, and other severe injuries.
Police apprehended Baker after a widespread island manhunt. He was reportedly driving a woman from Hilo to a store before the victims were found. During that drive, Baker offered a newly purchased knife and threatened to “shank all the rapists in Pahoa.” He allegedly spoke of cutting up rapists and pedophiles with machetes, and he purchased brass knuckles on the day of the killings.
In court filings, Baker is ordered held without bail. A mental fitness report is due August 4, with the next hearing scheduled for August 11.
