NEW YORK (AP) — Luigi Mangione is back in court as he seeks to bar New York prosecutors from using potentially incriminating evidence in the trial for the murder of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson. The pretrial hearing resumed on Tuesday after starting the previous day, during which the prosecution showcased surveillance videos captured during the December 4, 2024, incident, as well as footage from five days later that captured Mangione's arrest at a McDonald's in Pennsylvania.
Mangione's demeanor was tense as he absorbed the audio from a 911 call made by a McDonald's manager, who expressed concerns about a customer resembling the suspect in the shooting of Thompson. The defense team argues that the evidence obtained—including a handgun matching the murder weapon and a notebook detailing Mangione's intentions—should be excluded, claiming the police lacked a warrant for the search of his backpack.
Judge Gregory Carro is presiding over the hearing, where it was noted that Mangione had previously provided false identification to law enforcement before being fully informed of his rights. His attorneys also contend that statements made under questioning without due process should not be admissible.
Mangione, heir to a wealthy Maryland family and a graduate of an Ivy League university, has pleaded not guilty to both state and federal charges related to the murder, which carries a potential sentence of life imprisonment, with federal authorities seeking the death penalty.
The hearing could extend throughout the week, with law enforcement witnesses expected to testify about the details surrounding both the murder and Mangione's arrest. As the trial continues, the courtroom has attracted supporters advocating for the accused, claiming violations of his rights.
