Skip to main content
Quanta Report

The Cost of Silence: Umar Khalid and the State's Repression in Modi's India

A prominent activist faces four years of imprisonment without trial, highlighting the chilling effect of dissent suppression under India's current government.

By Suhasini RajSource: nytimes.com1 min read
The Cost of Silence: Umar Khalid and the State's Repression in Modi's India
Image via nytimes.com

In brief

As families gather for virtual calls to imprisoned political activist Umar Khalid, his continued detention signifies a broader trend of repression against dissenters in India, particularly Muslims opposing Prime Minister Narendra Modi's regime.

In the vibrant city of New Delhi, a weekly familial ritual unfolds as loved ones converge around a laptop to connect with Umar Khalid, a prominent political activist currently enduring his fourth year of incarceration without trial. His mother, Sabiha Khanam, alongside other relatives from both local and international locations, eagerly awaits his familiar voice. "How are you, Ammi?" Khalid calls out warmly, his efforts to engage everyone in the frame underscoring the familial bond that withstands the barriers of his confinement. Rising to prominence during India's powerful protests in early 2020 against government initiatives perceived as anti-Muslim, Khalid's dissent has rendered him a significant figure in the ongoing struggle for rights and justice. His arrest later that year has made him emblematic of the expanding crackdown on opposition under Prime Minister Narendra Modi, despite a shifting political landscape following recent elections.The Modi government has increasingly relied on strict security laws traditionally reserved for violent uprisings, utilizing them to quash dissent across the country. These laws grant authorities the power to detain activists indefinitely, often resulting in dire circumstances for those awaiting preliminary judgment. Tragically, some individuals facing such prolonged detentions have died without ever receiving bail, while many others find themselves entangled in protracted legal procedures that stretch into years.As lawmakers and critics continue to assess the implications of Modi's regime, the plight of Umar Khalid serves as a stark reminder of the high price of dissent in contemporary India. His situation encapsulates a troubling trend – one where silencing opposition has become an entrenched governmental strategy.

Topics

More on this story