Kasem Abu al-Hija lost his daughter and two granddaughters in a missile strike that revealed the lack of public bomb shelters in his Arab-majority town compared to nearby Jewish areas. The attack intensified discussions about systemic discrimination against Arab citizens in Israel, particularly in terms of emergency resources.
"Tragedy in Tamra: A Father's Grief Highlights Societal Divisions in Israel"

"Tragedy in Tamra: A Father's Grief Highlights Societal Divisions in Israel"
The recent missile strike in Tamra, which claimed the lives of four family members, unveils disparities in emergency preparedness and societal equality between Arab and Jewish communities in Israel.
Kasem Abu al-Hija, aged 67, stands engulfed in grief after losing four family members in a devastating missile strike that struck his home in Tamra, an Arab-majority town in northern Israel. The attack occurred on Saturday when an Iranian missile collapsed their residence, killing his 45-year-old daughter Manar Khatib, his granddaughters Shada, 20, and Hala, 13, along with their 41-year-old aunt, Manal Khatib. As rescue teams searched through the debris, witnesses reported horrifying scenes of scattered belongings and body parts strewn across the road.
Eyewitnesses recounted that the entire street was enveloped in darkness when the missile hit. Among the debris, videos surfaced online showing Israelis celebrating and chanting anti-Arab slogans moments after the tragedy. "They sang about what happened to my family," Kasem remarked with a heavy heart, confronting a broader societal divide as President Isaac Herzog condemned the celebratory video as “appalling and disgraceful.”
The outrage within Kasem's community is exacerbated by the absence of public bomb shelters—a stark contrast to the neighboring Jewish-majority town of Karmiel, which boasts a significantly higher number of shelters for its residents. Local leaders have long decried the disparity in emergency preparedness. According to a State Comptroller report, approximately half of Arab communities lack adequate bomb shelter facilities, while only about a quarter of the general Israeli population is similarly disadvantaged.
For Tamra's 38,000 residents, this inequality manifests into life-threatening reality during escalated conflicts, especially with nearby threats from Hezbollah. Despite the mandated construction of reinforced safe rooms in new residential buildings throughout Israel, many Arab communities don't meet the infrastructure requirements due to stringent planning restrictions, leaving about 60% of Tamra's residents without safe rooms in their homes.
This crisis has led community representatives, such as Adel Khatib, to voice deep frustrations over deprived funding and resources directed towards Arab communities. "In the days since this happened, you can feel the anger," Khatib expressed, underscoring the systemic inequities affecting education, employment, and basic community needs.
As sirens shriek warnings and panic spreads across Tamra following missile alerts, the fear among residents escalates. Feedback from ongoing surveys indicates an overwhelming majority of Jewish Israelis support military actions against Iran, while a significant portion of Arab citizens express fear and despair over the situation. The ongoing conflict has been exacerbated by deep-seated grievances of neglect among the Arab populace, facing a severe poverty rate exceeding double that of the general Israeli population.
Activists and local authorities are pressing for improvements amidst a challenging governmental landscape. Many feel the current right-wing coalition has tightened funding for development initiatives aimed at bridging societal gaps. As communities gather to mourn and reflect on the tragic loss, the cry for change resonates: “The bombs do not choose between Arabs or Jews. We must end this war. We must end it now,” Kasem declared, summoning the strength of shared humanity in the face of deepening divides.