Fine Imposed for Loudspeaker Use at French Train Station

Tue Sep 23 2025 09:11:55 GMT+0300 (Eastern European Summer Time)

A man faces a €200 fine after using loudspeaker mode during a phone call at a Nantes train station, highlighting differing attitudes toward public phone etiquette.

A 54-year-old man, identified only as David, was recently fined €200 for making a phone call on loudspeaker in a French train station, sparking debate over public phone etiquette and noise regulations. David, speaking to BFM TV, recounted his experience at Nantes station where he was approached by an SNCF employee who threatened him with a €150 fine if he did not end the loudspeaker call. When David failed to pay immediately, the fine was reportedly escalated to €200. This incident has since prompted David to seek legal assistance to challenge the fine.

While French noise control laws do not explicitly address loudspeaker phone calls, the Transport Code stipulates that actions causing disturbance in public transport can result in penalties. Though SNCF confirmed the fine, they contested certain claims made by David. Public opinion data reveals widespread disapproval of loudspeaker use in shared spaces, with recent surveys indicating that a significant majority of respondents are opposed to such behavior. Other countries have adopted varying methods to manage noise in public transport, from designated quiet zones in the UK to strict cultural norms against phone use in Japan and South Korea.

This incident is a reflection of the ongoing conversation around public behavior, noise regulation, and the etiquette of phone conversations in shared environments worldwide.